Tuesday, December 5, 2023

NYFF60 Preview And What It Means For The Oscar Race

The 60th anniversary of the New York Film Festival begins tomorrow, September 30th, with the Opening Night film Noah Baumbach’s “White Noise.” It will continue until October 14th with the Closing Night film, Elegance Bratton’s “The Inspection.” Laura Poitras’ Venice Golden Lion-winning documentary film “All The Beauty And The Bloodshed” will be the Centerpiece Film. Representing the celebration of 60 years is New York native James Gray’s film “Armageddon Time,” which will play near the end of the festival. Two highly anticipated world premieres are Maria Schrader’s “She Said” and Chinonye Chukwu’s “Till.” There are also several films playing in the Revivals and Currents sections, while also featuring lots of Talks with filmmakers on their movies and the industry’s current state. It’s an exciting time to be a film fan if you live anywhere near New York over the next two weeks. What does this festival mean for the Oscar race, though?

One of the things I’d like to show you all is how many Best Picture nominees have played at NYFF since the expanded lineup was introduced at the Oscars back in 2009.

Precious: Based on the Novel “Push” by Sapphire (Centerpiece)

The Social Network (Opening Night – World Premiere)

The Artist
The Descendants (Closing Night)
Hugo (Unfinished workprint – World Premiere)

Life Of Pi (Opening Night – World Premiere)
Lincoln (Unfinished workprint – World Premiere)

12 Years A Slave
Captain Phillips (Opening Night – World Premiere)
Her (Closing Night – World Premiere)

Birdman (Closing Night)

Bridge Of Spies (World Premiere)

Manchester By The Sea

Call Me By Your Name
Lady Bird

The Favourite (Opening Night)
Roma (Centerpiece)

The Irishman (Opening Night – World Premiere)
Marriage Story (Centerpiece)

Nomadland (Centerpiece)

Drive My Car
The Power Of The Dog (Centerpiece)

“The Artist,” “12 Years A Slave,” “Birdman,” “Moonlight,” and “Parasite” all went on to win Best Picture. So, based on what we see here, we can expect anywhere between one or three Best Picture nominees to play at this year’s festival. I’ve been fortunate to have already seen a number of the films programmed, and if I had to guess what those three Best Picture nominees are, they’d be…

She Said (Dir. Maria Schrader)
TÁR (Dir. Todd Field)
Women Talking (Dir. Sarah Polley)

None of these three films come from one of the Gala nights, but of the three playing in those prestigious slots, I’d say “White Noise” is the closest due to the power of Netflix behind it. The Don DeLillo adaptation represents Baumbach’s most ambitious film to date, and hot off of his most tremendous success yet with Academy voters with “Marriage Story,” they might be open to welcoming him back again so soon. Yes, the reactions out of Venice weren’t necessarily the strongest. Still, Netflix is in desperate need of a significant Best Picture contender right now, and it’s possible NYFF might give this film the shot in the arm it needs to be taken seriously for a nomination.

Unlike Venice, Telluride, or TIFF, NYFF doesnt play the largest role in helping us figure out what might be nominated for Best Picture. It can help us find a contender here or there, and it certainly can help elevate a film’s status post those other major festivals (since NYFF is the last major one before the regionals begin). But the real question is how many Best International Feature Oscar nominees have played at NYFF over the last few years? NYFF is known for taking the “best of” Cannes and having those films re-enter the conversation alongside specifically curated films from Berline and Venice. In many ways, NYFF is a culmination of all of the major film festivals that came before it, making it highly unique in the Oscar race. So how many International Feature Film Oscar nominees have played at NYFF since 2009? Let’s take a look…

The White Ribbon


A Separation


The Missing Picture



Toni Erdmann

The Square

Cold War

Pain And Glory


Drive My Car
The Worst Person In The World

Best International Feature Film Oscar winners that have played NYFF recently include “A Separation,” “Amour,” “Roma,” “Parasite,” and “Drive My Car.” Surprisingly, despite having a heavy international offering each year, fewer Oscar nominees for Best International Feature Film emerge from NYFF than you would think. In fact, only 19 Best International Feature Film Oscar nominees play at NYFF vs. the 28 overall Best Picture nominees we counted before (with an overlap of four films – “Amour,” “Roma,” “Parasite,” and “Drive My Car“). Part of the reason why this is lower than you would expect is because of the country selection process, which takes place during this time of year with the deadline fast approaching on October 3rd. 

So far, here are the films that their countries have selected to contend for the Oscar for Best International Feature Film playing at NYFF this year…

Alcarràs (Spain) (Dir. Carla Simón)
Corsage (Austria) (Dir. Marie Kreutzer)
Decision To Leave (South Korea) (Dir. Park Chan-wook)
EO (Poland) (Dir. Jerzy Skolimowski)
Saint Omer (France) (Dir. Alice Diop)

Each of these still stands a good chance of getting an Oscar nomination for Best International Feature Film, but judging on the recent trends, only one or two of them will likely make the final cut. Currently, Next Best Picture believes those two films will be “Decision To Leave” and “Saint Omer,” but it’s still a long season ahead, and a lot can change.

The Best Documentary Feature race is also starting to take shape, and special consideration should be given to the films playing at this year’s festival. I’d say the four documentary feature films worth keeping an eye on for this year’s Oscar race are… 

All That Breathes (Dir. Shaunak Sen)
All The Beauty And The Bloodshed (Dir. Laura Poitras)
Descendant (Dir. Margaret Brown)
Sr. (Dir. Chris Smith)

I’ve seen all four of these, and they all rank among my top ten best documentaries I’ve seen this year. Each of them currently has a decent shot of being nominated for Best Documentary Feature at this year’s Academy Awards.

So, where does this leave us with NYFF being the last major stop on the fall film festival circuit before the other regional festivals begin and the precursor awards start shortly after? The New York Film Festival has more to offer than just serving as another launching pad for films in the awards conversation. There’s a treasure chest of quality filmmaking, challenging stories, and memorable experiences to be found amongst the lineup if you’re bold enough to look. Here are a few recommended titles playing at this year’s festival that I have not yet mentioned….

Aftersun (Dir. Charlotte Wells)
Bones And All (Dir. Luca Guadagnino)
Enys Men (Dir. Mark Jenkin)
The Eternal Daughter (Dir. Joanna Hogg)
Master Gardener (Dir. Paul Schrader)
No Bears (Dir. Jafar Panahi)
One Fine Morning (Dir. Mia Hansen-Løve)
R.M.N. (Dir. Cristian Mungiu)
Return To Seoul (Dir. Davy Chou)
Showing Up (Dir. Kelly Reichardt)
Triangle Of Sadness (Dir. Ruben Östlund)

What are you most excited to see at this year’s New York Film Festival? Do you think it will have any impact on this year’s awards race? Available tickets for NYFF60 can be found here. Please let us know your thoughts either in the comments section below or on our Twitter account.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter!

Matt Neglia
Matt Negliahttps://nextbestpicture.com/
Obsessed about the Oscars, Criterion Collection and all things film 24/7. Critics Choice Member.

Related Articles

Stay Connected


Latest Reviews