With “Elsinore” starting its theatrical run and precursor nominations and awards looming, Andrew Scott will soon test how strong a Best Actor challenger he can be to presumed favorites John Malkovich and Matt Damon. But two different past Best Actor races point to how Scott can win, though one depends on “Elsinore” getting into Best Picture, and the other shows how he can survive the film getting snubbed.
Right now, Scott is a likely soon-to-be first-time Oscar nominee from a Focus Features film, whose primary competition is an older veteran that seems destined to ride an “overdue” narrative towards a long-awaited Oscar, with the added advantage of being in a much stronger film from Searchlight Pictures. Yet in 2014, that exact scenario didn’t propel Michael Keaton to victory for “Birdman,” as presumed underdog Eddie Redmayne from “The Theory of Everything” eventually caught him despite losing for most of the season.
Redmayne rallied in part because “The Theory of Everything” held as a Best Picture nominee with five nominations overall, which gave Redmayne just enough of a boost to beat the lead from the eventual Best Picture winner. Over the last 16 years, Best Actor winners have needed to be from a Best Picture nominee to win, whether their films are win-competitive elsewhere or not – yet there has been one exception Scott may need to take inspiration from.
If “Elsinore” misses Best Picture, Scott will need to repeat what Brendan Fraser did after “The Whale” missed in 2022. Like Scott, Fraser had to rally back against a preseason favorite from a Martin McDonagh/Searchlight film, and also fend off the lead of a major summer blockbuster. In that case, Fraser did eventually hold off “The Banshees of Inisherin’s” Colin Farrell and “Elvis’s” Austin Butler despite being from a non-Best Picture nominee, which Scott might yet have to repeat against “Wild Horse Nine’s” Malkovich and “The Odyssey’s” Damon.
If “Elsinore” does get into Best Picture and gives Scott a chance to match Redmayne’s path, there are still some other differences to note from 2014. Redmayne was the relative newcomer that year compared to Keaton, despite appearances in Oscar-nominated films like “Les Misérables” and “My Week with Marilyn” beforehand. Yet Scott has been more well known going into “Elsinore” than Redmayne might have been before “The Theory of Everything,” thanks to Scott’s work in shows like “Fleabag” and “Sherlock,” and films like “All of Us Strangers,” “Blue Moon,” and “1917.”
In that context, Scott is in a better position than Redmayne was, though they are both in the same boat: transforming into real-life, inspirational figures while fighting for their lives and professional recognition in Focus Features tearjerkers. For Redmayne, his transformation as Stephen Hawking in “The Theory of Everything” was obviously more physically demanding, although Scott has his own transformational effect as Ian Charleson, who fights AIDS while trying to complete his last role as Hamlet on stage.
But despite how both Redmayne and Scott play to the rafters and the most traditional Oscar voters and audiences, they weren’t considered the top Best Actor favorites early in the season. For Redmayne, he looked like an afterthought, while Keaton had all the early-season raves, narrative advantages, and the seemingly decisive edge of leading a Best Picture frontrunner. Most of the precursor awards backed that up as well, with Keaton nearly sweeping those early awards as Redmayne was nearly shut out – save for winning the New York Film Critics Online award, and the Golden Globe for Best Actor Drama where he didn’t have to face Keaton. In fact, it took winning BAFTA and then SAG for Redmayne to even look like a possible Oscar winner at all.
Redmayne still has the fewest overall wins for a Best Actor Oscar winner in the expanded era, which is just one reason why the outcome remains so puzzling years later. Nevertheless, Redmayne proved that hanging around long enough to beat a seemingly overwhelming favorite at the very end can be done – so is that something Scott will have to do as well?
Malkovich has the same kind of narrative and sentiment behind him for “Wild Horse Nine” as Keaton did for “Birdman” in 2014, but perhaps he might have a harder time sweeping every critics award and early precursor. For one thing, whereas “Birdman” was the eventual Best Picture winner, “Wild Horse Nine” doesn’t look nearly as strong against current leaders like “The Odyssey,” “La Bola Negra,” and possibly “Dune: Part Three” and “You Can See Everything.” Without a sure-fire top-tier frontrunner behind him, perhaps Malkovich will be a bit easier to catch – like the last Best Actor favorite from a McDonagh/Searchlight movie.
When Fraser won in 2022, it helped that “The Banshees of Inisherin” faded from Best Picture contender to a film that didn’t win a single Oscar, which also doomed top critics’ precursor winner Farrell. Given that history and how “Wild Horse Nine” already doesn’t seem as strong across the board, could it become a second straight McDonagh film to fade after nomination morning and take Malkovich down with it this time? Even if that happens, could Damon do what Butler didn’t and fill the gap for a much stronger summer blockbuster turned Oscar contender than “Elvis” in “The Odyssey” – or what if “The Odyssey” doesn’t need him to win, just like how “Birdman” didn’t need a Keaton win to take Best Picture?
If “Elsinore” misses Best Picture and forces Scott to repeat what Fraser did, there are some other differences with that race as well. Fraser had a comeback narrative of his own on his side, and was more of a blockbuster leading man in years past than Scott has been. And while both Fraser and Scott played dying characters, Fraser did so while under heavy prosthetics as a 600-pound man. That helped “The Whale” offset its Best Picture snub by winning the Best Makeup and Hairstyling Oscar, giving Fraser the safety net he needed.
“The Whale” also helped him by getting Hong Chau a Best Supporting Actress nomination, which is exactly what “Elsinore” can do if it slips Olivia Colman into that category as well. If Scott and Colman are “Elsinore’s” only nominations and it misses categories like Best Makeup, Best Original Screenplay, and Best Casting to go along with Best Picture, would that alone keep Scott from doing what Fraser did?
Like Redmayne, Fraser wasn’t the leading Best Actor precursor winner, although he won a lot more critics’ prizes than Redmayne did. And while Fraser didn’t win a Golden Globe or BAFTA like Redmayne, taking SAG was all he ultimately needed to seize last-second momentum, exactly like Redmayne did. Right now, it seems a little less certain that Scott could beat the likes of Malkovich and Damon at SAG/the Actor Awards, but Fraser and Redmayne didn’t look like their obvious choices going in either.
No matter how “Elsinore” looks with Best Picture precursor nominations and mentions on its resume, Scott surely won’t be almost shut out in critics season like Redmayne was, even if he doesn’t win as many regional awards as Fraser did. He seems more likely to repeat what Redmayne did by winning the Drama Golden Globe, and would seem an obvious choice to win BAFTA, as Redmayne did. Yet if “Elsinore” isn’t a Best Picture nominee by then like “The Theory of Everything” was, will that stop any momentum Scott might have by Oscar night?
“Elsinore” could overperform on Oscar nomination morning like “The Theory of Everything” did and launch Scott from there, especially given how this year’s Best Actor race has echoed 2014 so far. It could also underperform on nomination morning like “The Whale” did, albeit not quite enough to count Scott out and give him wiggle room to rally like Fraser. Yet if Scott is the sole nominee for “Elsinore,” all of this will be a moot point – unless the 2014 lead acting winner Scott echoes isn’t Redmayne, but Julianne Moore as the Best Actress winner and solo nominee for “Still Alice.”
Given how Fraser defied years of recent Best Actor history by winning when “The Whale” missed out on Best Picture, Scott winning as “Elsinore’s” only nominee is too improbable to picture right now. As such, it either has to be like “The Theory of Everything,” or “The Whale” in the worst-case but still survivable scenario, for Scott to remain a win-competitive option.
To those who think Malkovich is too beloved, too overdue, and too well-known to lose or for someone like Scott to beat him, the Keaton-Redmayne race shows exactly how wrong that thinking could be. To those who think “Elsinore” will weigh Scott down too much if it doesn’t make Best Picture, “The Whale” and Fraser show there is a way to overcome that. But if “Elsinore” isn’t like one or the other after all, can Scott find a different way to win, like Redmayne and Fraser had to?
Do you think Andrew Scott will win Best Actor for “Elsinore?” Do you have the film getting nominated for Best Picture? Please let us know in the comments section below and on Next Best Picture’s X account, and check out Next Best Picture’s latest Oscar predictions here.

