Saturday, May 18, 2024


THE STORY – A semi-autobiographical comedy-drama about Pete Davidson growing up in Staten Island, including losing his father during 9/11 and entering the world of stand up comedy.

THE CAST – Pete Davidson, Marisa Tomei, Bill Burr, Bel Powley, Maude Apatow & Steve Buscemi

THE TEAMJudd Apatow (Director/Writer), Pete Davidson & Dave Sirus & Michael Green (Writers)

136 Minutes

​By Matt Neglia

Judd Apatow has always had a knack for taking his ridiculous, over the top, misfit characters and infusing them with enough warmth and depth that we are easily able to relate with them as they go on their journeys. Whether it’s a 40-year-old geek trying to lose his virginity, or a downbeat stoner coming to grips with becoming a father, or a comedian who is going through a mid-life crisis, Apatow always manages to find the humanity within his characters, elevating his comedies beyond entertainment and into the profound territory. Not only has he done it again with “The King Of Staten Island”, but his latest might just be his best effort yet at peeling back the layers of his characters, breaking down our misconceived perceptions of them and finding something relatable and universal.

Scott (Pete Davidson) is a mid-twenty something year old, living at home with his mom (Marisa Tomei) and sister (Maude Apatow) in Staten Island. With no clear direction for where his life is heading, he spends most of his time smoking weed with his friends, occasionally drawing (pretty bad) tattoos on them (he has hopes of one day opening up a tattoo restaurant called “Ruby Tat Tuesdays”) and having empty sex with his friend Kelsey (Bel Powley), who wants him to truly commit to a relationship with her. Scott has never been the same since his fireman father died years ago when he was 7 in a fire and now, with his sister going off to college, the only person he has left in his life is his mom. However, that all changes when she starts dating Raymond Bishop (Bill Burr), who also happens to be a fireman. This enrages Scott, as he sets out to dismantle his mother’s new relationship. Antagonistic at first, Ray makes an attempt to form a relationship with Scott as he brings him to the firehouse and introduces him to his crew (including a wonderfully effective Steve Buscemi – who used to be a real volunteer firefighter). With not many choices left in his life, Scott reluctantly decides to work at the firehouse, where he might discover the true meaning of responsibility, the importance of heroes, and how to be open about his feelings.

The usual Judd Apatow trademarks are on full display in “The King Of Staten Island”: pop culture references, deadbeat protagonists whose lives are deteriorating from a series of bad decisions (mostly involving drugs), and of course, a long runtime. However, where a movie such as “Funny People” with a near two and a half hour runtime crumbled apart the longer it went on, “The King Of Staten Island” is Apatow’s most focused film yet. Careful consideration, time, and devotion are given to the characters aiding us to better understand their motivations, feelings, and struggles. Ditching the mainstream studio polish that is often given to comedy films, “The King Of Staten Island” undertakes an indie aesthetic that feels authentic, sincere and never has a single agenda on its mine other than to highlight the characters and let them drive the story. As a result, “The King Of Staten Island” is not only Judd Apatow’s most mature film to date, but also his most dramatic.

Pete Davidson’s Scott is deeply struggling with how to properly function in society since the loss of his firefighter father at an early age. He’s not mentally ok, as he’s also struggling with bipolar disorder while living with his mom well into his twenties. These elements are all pulled from his own life story and he tackles his demons head-on, turning in a surprisingly dramatic performance that is equally as light-hearted, charming, and funny, as it is raw and emotionally vulnerable. It’s easily his best performance yet and will surely open up more doors for him in Hollywood to continue his acting career beyond SNL. Marisa Tomei and Bill Burr also turn in strong performances, with an equal amount of attention being paid to their characters as much as Davidson’s. Burr, in particular, leans on his angry New England persona to great effect as he executes perfect line deliveries with impeccable comic timing. And Marisa Tomei exudes the right amount of compassion for her son but also frustration, which allows the Academy Award-winning actress to once again remind us just what an underutilized talent she really is.

Whether it’s a therapeutic showcase role for Davidson or a tribute to local everyday heroes (in this case, firemen), “The King Of Staten Island” stays on course and never deviates due to the strength of its characters. I’m sure there will be some who will still complain that the film is too long and the story stretched too thin but I would argue that the time spent on developing the characters and thus, allowing the actors to deliver natural, and fully formed performances all attributes toward making “The King Of Staten Island” Judd Apatow’s best film yet. Without giving any spoilers, look no further than the final few minutes of this movie, where Apatow delivers his most considered ending yet, highlighting his growth as a storyteller and a filmmaker. It may not all add up to be his funniest film (there are still quite a few great laughs). However, in terms of writing, performances, sheer craftsmanship (Robert Elswit’s cinematography looks terrific and the film’s editing montages are all well placed) and storytelling, Apatow reminds us all why he’s the kind of modern-day comedy.


THE GOOD – Tremendous character work done by the ensemble, aided by a lengthy runtime that never loses focus. Equally dramatic as it is funny. Judd Apatow’s most mature film yet.

THE BAD – That long runtime, no matter how well you argue it, may still turn people off regardless.


Subscribe to Our Newsletter!

Matt Neglia
Matt Neglia
Obsessed about the Oscars, Criterion Collection and all things film 24/7. Critics Choice Member.

Related Articles

Stay Connected


Latest Reviews