Every awards season brings debate over which films deserve the final Best Picture slots. Last year it was “F1” over the likes of “It Was Just an Accident” and “Weapons,” and this year it seems two movies on the bubble will either fight for the “honor” of being this year’s “Oscar villain” or share it together.
Among movies on the bubble, “You Can See Everything,” “All of a Sudden,” and “Possible Love” have the highest critic ratings and most passionate online fans, while the likes of “Artificial” and “Obsession” have their share of passion for various elements and their performances as well. But unlike those movies, “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” are the most traditional and conventionally appealing choices on the bubble – which is why there may be a loud outcry in some online corners if one or both of them snub out the “cooler” options.
Those sections of Oscar fandom will insist that the Best Picture field doesn’t need either of them, and there is still a scenario where neither gets in. But if older or more conventional voters still push one of them into the field, which one will it be, if not both of them?
“Elsinore” starts its limited release on November 20th, the same day that “I Play Rocky” expands into its wide release. Here are the other ways these two potential kindred spirits and potential rivals stack up.
Oscar-Winning Pedigree
To those who believe certain voters choose movies because they remind them of other films they voted for before, “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” are both perfect examples that back up that theory. Not only do both have ties to movies that won Best Picture decades ago, but they also have ties to very traditional, sentimental movies that won before.
“I Play Rocky” is by far the most explicit example, since it is literally the story of how 1976 Best Picture winner “Rocky” was made, and is itself an Oscar-friendly celebration of the power of art, movies, and defying Hollywood rules. “Elsinore’s” link to Oscar history is in the background since it is about Ian Charleson, one of the stars of the 1981 Best Picture “Chariots of Fire.” Nonetheless, it is centered years later when Charleson is dying of AIDS, and when he is trying to star on stage in “Hamlet” during his final months.
“Rocky” and “Chariots of Fire” are held as primary examples of the kind of broad, crowd-pleasing, tear-jerking films that once won Best Picture all the time – and the kind of films newer and “hipper” audiences tend to see as getting in the way of more experimental and untraditional contenders. As such, if the ghosts of “Rocky” or “Chariots of Fire” return to snub out one or multiple untraditional contenders in 2026, it wouldn’t be the first time.
Low Review Scores By Comparison
There are anywhere from 13 to 15 movies with realistic shots at Best Picture nominations, and both “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” have the lowest critical esteem among them. At a certain angle on Rotten Tomatoes, it doesn’t look that way, since “Elsinore” has an 89 percent score on the Tomatometer and “I Play Rocky” is at 86 percent as of November 15 – with both above or tied with presumed Best Picture frontrunner “La Bola Negra.” Yet as always on Rotten Tomatoes and on Metacritic, one has to look closer.
“Elsinore” has a 7.8 average critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes while “I Play Rocky” is at a 7.3 average – both at or near the bottom among possible nominees. Meanwhile, on Metacritic, “Elsinore” is at 75 while “I Play Rocky” is at 68. While “Elsinore” is technically just one or two points behind various stronger Best Picture contenders and tied with fellow bubble film “Artificial,” “I Play Rocky” would still be in Metacritic’s bottom tier of Best Picture nominees in the expanded era, one point below “F1.”
Either way, compared to a film at 97 on Metacritic like “You Can See Everything,” at 95 like “Possible Love,” or a film in the high 80s like “All of a Sudden,” “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” have a harder time passing that kind of eye test. Of course, Academy voters don’t often take that type of eye test into consideration.
Lead Actor Frontrunners
The main reason “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” have gotten this far may not be reviews or long-ago stars, but the current stars playing them. Their lead performances have attracted particular praise, while their overall reviews trail several competing films.
For Andrew Scott, being win-competitive against frontrunners like John Malkovich and Matt Damon is almost single-handedly keeping “Elsinore” alive. Anthony Ippolito may not be considered likely to win right now, but getting in on nomination morning could tip everybody off that “I Play Rocky” would be a Best Picture nominee minutes later. And if “Elsinore” is too weak to help Scott, if “The Odyssey” doesn’t need Damon to win or becomes too vulnerable to push him over, and if “Wild Horse Nine” fades after the nominations and takes Malkovich down with it, then Ippolito – if not “I Play Rocky” in general – could become a greater threat to be more than a mere nominee.
Yet right now, Scott is the only one deemed locked for a Best Actor nomination while Ippolito remains on the bubble – which gives “Elsinore” a major leg up on “I Play Rocky” for the moment.
Limited Nomination Options Everywhere Else
Although their lead actors are the best shots, “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” have to support their Best Picture case; the worst case against them is their potential inability to get in anywhere else.
There are no options for either to get into Best Actress, and neither has anyone stood out enough to get traction into Best Supporting Actor. Best Supporting Actress offers some hope to “Elsinore,” if only because it has past winner and frequent nominee Olivia Colman to offer up – and yet many have cited Billie Piper as the film’s standout supporting actress instead. Nonetheless, Colman’s Academy credentials have convinced some that voters will check her in anyway, if only to justify “Elsinore” getting into Best Picture and help Scott’s case for Best Actor.
There is some vague hope for both films to get a Screenplay nomination, even though no one knows yet if “I Play Rocky” will be submitted as an Original or Adapted screenplay. “Elsinore” is seemingly set in Original, so it may benefit if “I Play Rocky” goes to Adapted. But there are several other bubble films like “Artificial,” “Obsession, and “Fjord,” and potential solo nominees like “Club Kid” and “Tender Loving Care,” considered ahead of both of them in the Original field anyway.
Since both “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” have a variety of people playing real-life actors and recognizable figures, some speculate that could help them get into Best Casting. But is that field also too crowded with solid Best Picture contenders and films that have made bigger casting discoveries? And if it is, what becomes of “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” should most, if not all, other fields turn out the same?
Studio Priorities
Being a studio’s No. 1 film helps a great deal with getting into Best Picture. Neither “Elsinore” nor “I Play Rocky” can say they have that advantage yet, but each may have room to move up later.
“I Play Rocky” has a harder uphill battle as an Amazon/MGM film, with “Project Hail Mary” being that studio’s top priority since March. But with constant speculation that “Project Hail Mary” will keep getting weaker the longer the season goes on, and with “I Play Rocky” being both based on a Best Picture winner and made by the director of another in “Green Book,” Peter Farrelly, theories continue that Amazon will ultimately shift its priorities to “I Play Rocky” if it can’t get both films in.
“Elsinore” is almost in the same boat at Focus Features, as “Obsession” has been its own record-setting box office smash and top priority since early in the season. But with “Obsession” clearly getting weaker itself the longer the season goes on, with Scott being the kind of win-competitive lead acting frontrunner that “Obsession’s” Inde Navarrette may not be anymore, and with “Elsinore” playing to a much more traditional base of Academy voters than “Obsession,” theories continue that Focus will put all its hopes on “Elsinore” if it can’t get two films in like last year.
Focus almost always gets at least one film into Best Picture, and Amazon/MGM has gotten one in four of the last five years. As such, if “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” become those studios’ No. 1 by January, their odds of getting in will improve greatly.
Audience Award Pedigree
In terms of nomination packages, “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” may be at various disadvantages. Yet no one cared about that when each won awards or placed high at film festivals this fall – festivals with similar tastes to Academy voters.
Both films cemented themselves on the bubble at TIFF, when “I Play Rocky” placed second for the overall People’s Choice and “Elsinore” was the surprise International People’s Choice winner. Since then, “I Play Rocky” has won awards at film festivals in cities like Denver, Virginia, and Vancouver, while “Elsinore” has been racking up awards at festivals in cities like San Diego, Chicago, Mill Valley, and Middleburg. In addition, “Elsinore” is also the most nominated film at the British Independent Film Awards.
Between that kind of audience devotion for “Elsinore,” and 50 years of audiences embracing the “Rocky” saga, the suspicion that Academy voters will easily fall in line may endure all the way to nomination morning, even if it has only one or two other nominations with it – and no matter what anyone else says about it later on.
What do you think will be nominated for Best Picture this year? Do you think “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” make it or just one of them? Please let us know in the comments section below and on Next Best Picture’s X account, and check out Next Best Picture’s latest Oscar predictions here.

