“THE HUNGER GAMES: SUNRISE ON THE REAPING”

THE STORY – Set in the world of Panem 24 years before the events of “The Hunger Games,” the story follows Haymitch into the arena, where he forms an unlikely alliance and joins a coalition determined to challenge the Capitol’s control under President Snow. As the competition unfolds, Haymitch risks everything to take down the Games from within the arena.

THE CAST – Joseph Zada, Mckenna Grace, Jesse Plemons, Ralph Fiennes, Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, Maya Hawke, Whitney Peak, Kelvin Harrison Jr. & Ben Wang

THE TEAM – Francis Lawrence (Director), Billy Ray & Michael Lesslie (Writers)

THE RUNNING TIME – 158 Minutes


In just two decades, one can confidently say that “The Hunger Games” franchise is a modern classic. The original trilogy by Suzanne Collins has sold over 100 million copies, and the film adaptations have inspired young adults worldwide, now reaching a second generation who were toddlers or not even alive when the first book was released in 2008. This is easily Generation Z’s “The Lord of the Rings” or “Harry Potter.” What Collins created was nothing short of a miracle – a dystopian world that not only entertained but educated young people about systems of abusive government, control, the weaponization of entertainment, and rebellion. And Lionsgate, along with longtime director Francis Lawrence, has brought these films to life wonderfully. So when Suzanne Collins finds more inspiration, it is natural to assume that a film will appear in the next 2-3 years. We saw that with the first prequel, “The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes,” published in 2020 and adapted into a film in 2023. With last year’s release of “Sunrise on the Reaping,” another novel following the events of the Second Quarter Quell – the games that featured District 12’s mentor Haymitch – it was only a matter of time before the book was going to be seen on screen; we just didn’t know how fast Lionsgate was working.

Unlike “Ballad,” “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” further examines the world of Panem leading up to the triumphant rebellion that Katniss symbolized. It’s 25 years before the inevitable Third Quarter Quell that will put her and Peeta back in the arena. Here, the surprise element is that there will be double the tributes: four from each District and 48 in total. From the original saga, one would assume a young Haymitch Abernathy, famously played by Woody Harrelson in the original films, would be a detestable young man on the way to alcoholism, but the contrary is true. Here, he (Joseph Zada) is full of light and shocking positivity as he wakes up on his 16th birthday, greeted with copious love from his friends, family, and girlfriend, Covey member Lenore Dove Baird (Whitney Peak). All of that changes, however, when Haymitch is selected as the second male tribute for District 12 by their escort, Drusilla (Glenn Close in a devilishly fantastic make-up job). He shares the bad luck with his close friend and young neighbor, Louella McCoy (Molly McCann); coal-miner Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang); and an opinionated Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace) from the merchant side of town. On their way to the Capitol, the four eventually decide to go through this horrific journey together, mostly for the sake of young Louella, who is hanging onto Haymitch like we saw Prim once did with Katniss. After all, this is a Quarter Quell, and therefore, everything is different.​

Suzanne Collins never just writes another “Hunger Games” story for the sake of fan service. She always makes sure there is a valid reason to entertain and educate her young readers. Here, the idea of what a government shows its audience is front and center. That theme is evident from the beginning of the film, surrounding how Haymitch becomes a tribute. This continues throughout the film as we see that what actually occurs differs from what the District and Capitol members watch on their screens. Even President Snow (Ralph Fiennes) deliberately mentions that he controls what the citizens of Panem witness. Though Haymitch wants to prove a point and is given the opportunity to join an alliance to “break the games,” Collins and Lawrence show that just because something was attempted doesn’t mean it will be shown to Panem. Therefore, the world Haymitch finds himself in is vastly different from what Panem is viewing.​

And that is interesting – attempting to destroy a system that is far bigger and stronger than you, that has made it clear that you will be destroyed if you attempt said journey (and that no one would even know about said attempt), which is why this version of Haymitch is both incredibly important to nail and cast. One needs to believe in this character’s mission – while knowing it will fail – and observe the innocence of a child being taken away. And by some miracle, they found the perfect Haymitch in Joseph Zada. With his incredibly charming Appalachian accent, the Haymitch of “Sunrise on the Reaping” is the antithesis of Woody Harrelson’s Haymitch; Zada brings a charming and lovable quality to the future mentor. It’s impossible not to root for Haymitch because Zada portrays him as someone with an inherently good soul who is brave, smart, and strong enough to fight for the collective, while knowing it is a near-impossible task. Therefore, one can feel his anguish at every obstacle he encounters. “Sunrise on the Reaping” is a tragedy; we watch a system break a strong-willed character, and Zada shows that tragedy on every level. He’s able to portray Haymitch’s heroic nature while also showing that he’s a terrified, overwhelmed 16-year-old. Nine times out of ten, casting directors couldn’t find a young talent to anchor an entire franchise, lead a film, and portray an iconic role, but Zada makes it look easy, proving there was no one else on the planet who could play Haymitch. It was a role he was truly born to play; a true star-is-born moment in a star-is-born role.

The rest of the cast also turns in compelling work. As fellow tributes, McCann, Wong, and Grace form a wonderful quartet with Zada. McCann portrays Louella as a young sweetheart trying to be as brave as she possibly can. Wong’s Wyatt has gambling experience, so his perspective on trying to get the best odds is an amusing new approach. And Grace’s Maysliee is tough as nails, consistently furious and not afraid to show her anger at her situation. Even with four distinct personalities, they all complement each other well, so watching them become a makeshift family is incredibly bittersweet. The silent glances they exchange before the parade and on the podiums are wonderfully painful, reminding us that, at the end of the day, they are all petrified children. On the Capitol side, Glenn Close is deliciously evil as Drusilla; Elle Fanning successfully captures Effie Trinket’s voice and demeanor; Kieran Culkin conveys his own extroverted, chaotic energy to Cesear Flickerman; Maya Hawke brings that quiet intellect we expect from Wiress but also a level of dissociation as the most recent Victor; and Kelvin Harrison Jr. absolutely nails Jeffrey Wright’s voice and physically brought Beetee to life while showcasing the horror of having to mentor his own son, Ampert (Percy Daggs IV). It is apparent that part of this film’s success lies in the casting. There are many characters at play, and most of them are younger versions of established characters. Casting directors Debra Zane and Dylan Jury have assembled an incredibly rich ensemble that not only honors the original actors, but helps create fully realized individuals.

However, the size of this ensemble is a detriment at times. The supporting character who receives the most screen time is Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons as the brilliant, matter-of-fact double agent that Philip Seymour Hoffman originated), and with trying to fit a story as vast as the 400-page novel into one film, the rest of the supporting characters suffer. There are too many legacy characters and actors that demand screen time. So much so that some of these characters are reduced to featured extras due to the runtime, only getting a scene or two. This is a common problem with “Hunger Games” adaptations, as the films don’t allow the audience enough time to bond with the supporting players, especially the fellow tributes. If anything, they are used like characters in horror films: once the games begin, if Haymitch spends time with someone, odds are the next scene will be their last, which makes their demise less impactful. It seems that maybe Suzanne Collins has outwritten the narrative feature medium, as more time is obviously needed to feel the full emotional depth.

But even with the pacing issues, director Francis Lawrence is still finding new avenues into this world, which is a rarity in franchise filmmaking. “Sunrise on the Reaping” looks vastly different from both the original saga and “The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes.” With the poisonous arena, the film has a psychedelic quality that emphasizes the colors purple, green, and yellow. It is reminiscent of “Alice in Wonderland,” where everything beautiful has a dangerous underbelly. This makes repetitive story beats (the reaping, training sequence, parade, etc.) feel new and exciting, demanding to be seen in IMAX (on the biggest screen possible). Lawrence deeply understands this world and the themes Collins writes about. Yet, there is a substantial lack of action and violence, suggesting that Lawrence is actively working to keep the film within the PG-13 rating, which undermines the monstrosity that is children fighting to the death. The lack of 87Eleven, the original stunt team, is not only missed but immensely felt.

Even though this is the most depressing Hunger Games film by far (bring all the tissues), there is still a strong component of hope, and that hope within sadness captures everything “The Hunger Games” is about. There is a full-circle element to the film that connects to the original saga, and if this is the end, it’s a very satisfying ending. “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” may be a tragedy at face value, but it is also about the fight for a better tomorrow and the willingness of ordinary young individuals to fight for it, knowing that they will probably not live to see that tomorrow. Something as big as a nationwide revolution takes time and luck, and it builds on generations of individuals slowly assembling that fire. Lawrence brilliantly shows that within “Sunrise on the Reaping.” Katniss would go on to be the fire, but Haymitch is the spark of the revolution. She would not have been successful without Haymitch, and his determination for the revolution stems from his interactions with the characters he meets here. Collins’s message here is potent: every step toward freedom is worth it, every loss is significant, and the eventual victory honors that memory, because the valor and spirit of those who fought are part of the reason why we won.

THE RECAP

THE GOOD - A triumphant return to Panem with an immensely talented cast, inspiring direction and production design. It comes full circle with the story of Panem’s rebellion.

THE BAD - The formula is beginning to become repetitive while the amount of characters allows little time to develop the supporting cast. There is a lack of action and violence compared to the original saga.

THE OSCAR PROSPECTS - Best Casting

THE FINAL SCORE - 7/10

Subscribe to Our Newsletter!

Lauren LaMagna
Lauren LaMagnahttps://nextbestpicture.com
Assistant arts editor at Daily Collegian. Film & TV copy editor.

Related Articles

Stay Connected

130,710FollowersFollow
130,710FollowersFollow
9,315FansLike
9,315FansLike
7,089FollowersFollow
7,089FollowersFollow
130,710FollowersFollow
9,315FansLike
8,269SubscribersSubscribe
7,089FollowersFollow
130,710FollowersFollow
9,315FansLike
7,089FollowersFollow
8,269SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Reviews

<b>THE GOOD - </b>A triumphant return to Panem with an immensely talented cast, inspiring direction and production design. It comes full circle with the story of Panem’s rebellion.<br><br> <b>THE BAD - </b>The formula is beginning to become repetitive while the amount of characters allows little time to develop the supporting cast. There is a lack of action and violence compared to the original saga.<br><br> <b>THE OSCAR PROSPECTS - </b><a href="/oscar-predictions-best-casting/">Best Casting</a><br><br> <b>THE FINAL SCORE - </b>7/10<br><br>"THE HUNGER GAMES: SUNRISE ON THE REAPING"