“MADDEN”

THE STORY – Chronicles John Madden’s incredible journey alongside best friend and true original Al Davis—from a Super Bowl-winning partnership with the Raiders, to becoming football’s most recognizable voice, to building the worldwide Madden NFL video game.

THE CAST – Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, John Mulaney, Sienna Miller & Shane Gillis

THE TEAM – David O. Russell (Director) & Cambron Clark (Writer)

THE RUNNING TIME – 110 Minutes


“Madden” is a more than curious departure from David O. Russell, a filmmaker desperate to wash the stink off of his latest feature “Amsterdam,” a disaster that further poked holes in the notion that he’s one of the more respectable filmmakers working today. O. Russell is certainly digging from the well, as sports have been central to some of his biggest hits like “Silver Linings Playbook” and “The Fighter.” Here he’s tackling (the pun is not intended) one of the larger-than-life figures of professional football. A name that is forever immortalized not only in the halls of Canton, Ohio, but at GameStops, or what’s left of them around the world. It’s only fitting that he enlists a performer whose bigger-than-the-big-screen style of acting, like Nicholas Cage, would make a fitting lead for what is the hopeful comeback film that would earn him his good graces and open arms amongst Hollywood. Instead, “Madden” does the opposite, proving that the best of O. Russell is behind him.

Any sense of prestige associated with O. Russell’s filmography not only dissipates with “Amsterdam” but is lost in the opening of “Madden,” where an SNL-esque sensibility clouds the filmmakers’ first foray into a film most boomers will watch at home on Prime Video. Cambron Clark’s screenplay places audiences in the late 70s, amid the Oakland Raiders’ reign of failure. Long-time partners John Madden (played by Cage), the team’s head coach, and owner Al Davis (played by Christian Bale) chase the tail of success that, for athletic sociopaths like all-time greats like Tom Brady or Michael Jordan, truly comes at the cost of everything. O. Russell establishes a faux documentary style but instantly abandons it, injecting fourth-wall breaks, straight-to-camera glances, and unrealistic moments of pageantry that feel ridiculous.

It’s all to distract from how Clark’s writing lacks cohesion in navigating the latter part of Madden’s career, especially given how choppily edited the film is. “Madden” moves through the titular figure’s various phases, through his coaching successes, transition into becoming the bona fide broadcasting celebrity that changes how we watch the sport, and, of course, the figurehead behind the multi-billion game franchise that E.A. milks every year with little to no alterations that justify paying full price for it just because it has a new cover athlete. O. Russell attempts to use John’s marital strife, Kathryn Hahn’s Virginia Madden, and his rocky relationship with Al as the bedrock for the film’s dramatic through-line, yet it does little to invest us beyond having his actors fire painstakingly humorless banter.

“Madden” props up the question: what’s the appeal these days in starring in one of O. Russell’s films? What it truly boils down to is the propped-up sense of permission from a “premiere” filmmaker to play up one’s performance that any actor is desperate to operate in. Well, that, and the fact that O. Russell usually has the Midas touch of getting his actors nominated for major awards, is enough for many to look past his notably problematic behavior behind the scenes. Yet for Cage, he is the living antithesis of O. Russell’s filmmaking essence. A brave performer whose innate sense of curiosity has led him to risky deviations in how he crafts his characters. O. Russell gives him no guidance or doesn’t attempt to reel him in, instead leaving Cage astray to do a mildly amusing impression that wears itself thin pretty quickly.

Strangely enough, Bale once again manages to barely glide through the thralls of O. Russell’s mismanaged direction, fittingly tapping into Al’s sensibility as the devil riding on Madden’s shoulders, parading him with the ideas of Football Valhalla, i.e., the Hall of Fame. It’s a solid performance, even if Bale at times teeters into Trumpish enunciations. It’s certainly better than Hahn’s performance, which contains none of the hallmarks of why she’s such a captivating performer and boxes her into a Carmela Soprano type housewife hammering the same narrative beats for the entirety of the film. At least Hahn is trying to deliver a performance compared to stand-up comedians like Shane Gillis or John Mulaney, where the latter is a far more prominent aspect of the final act of the film.

Mulaney’s Trip Hawkins, the mind behind Electronic Arts and Madden, is a bumbling nerd in the background, hovering until O. Russell is ready to cast him on screen while siphoning off any charm the comic so easily exudes. Gillis is merely playing a variation of himself as John’s neighbor Troy, a lifelong Raiders fan who is just the popular comic in old-school hairdues.
Many scenes lifelessly roll into one another, and even the work of the great Robert Richardson makes this maybe the blandest-looking film of O. Russell’s filmography. “Madden” is a CTE-induced biopic that is as laughable when John talks shop directly into the camera as it is when audiences watch him learn about N.W.A. from Al. It’s hard to imagine this coming so close to “Amsterdam” in terms of that film’s sloppiness, but surely O. Russell is ready to test our patience.

THE RECAP

THE GOOD - Christian Bale gives a solid performance and Nicholas Cage is amusing to watch at times.

THE BAD - David O. Russell direction is a mess for mismanaged biopic that is laughably as bad as "Amsterdam."

THE OSCAR PROSPECTS - None

THE FINAL SCORE - 3/10

Subscribe to Our Newsletter!

Giovanni Lago
Giovanni Lago
Devoted believer in all things cinema and television. Awards Season obsessive and aspiring filmmaker.

Related Articles

Stay Connected

130,710FollowersFollow
130,710FollowersFollow
9,315FansLike
9,315FansLike
7,089FollowersFollow
7,089FollowersFollow
130,710FollowersFollow
9,315FansLike
8,269SubscribersSubscribe
7,089FollowersFollow
130,710FollowersFollow
9,315FansLike
7,089FollowersFollow
8,269SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Reviews

<b>THE GOOD - </b>Christian Bale gives a solid performance and Nicholas Cage is amusing to watch at times.<br><br> <b>THE BAD - </b>David O. Russell direction is a mess for mismanaged biopic that is laughably as bad as "Amsterdam."<br><br> <b>THE OSCAR PROSPECTS - </b>None<br><br> <b>THE FINAL SCORE - </b>3/10<br><br>"MADDEN"