THE STORY – Eight years after the events of Once Upon a Time in… Hollywood, Cliff Booth returns to a changing Los Angeles. Now working as a fixer in the shadows of the Hollywood studio system, Cliff finds himself entangled in a dangerous web of secrets, crimes, and betrayals that will test everything he knows about loyalty and survival.
THE CAST – Brad Pitt, Elizabeth Debicki, Scott Caan, Yahya Abdul-Mateen II, Carla Gugino, Peter Weller, Matt Groove, JB Tadena, Corey Fogelmanis & Karren Karagulian
THE TEAM – David Fincher (Director) & Quentin Tarantino (Writer)
THE RUNNING TIME – 143 Minutes
In hindsight, “Once Upon a Time in…Hollywood” truly felt like Quentin Tarantino’s swan song. A reverent hangout flick that doubles as a time capsule of a period in this industry that has stuck with him forever, and a meta-esque rectification to put cinema back on a better path. It’s his most sentimental film, featuring characters he’s constantly returned to, most notably with a novelization and funeral podcast episodes, where Tarantino paid his respects to Rick Dalton like he was a lifelong friend. So it makes sense that a filmmaker with a self-imposed rule about the finality of his filmmaking career would struggle to land on what would be a grand send-off into the sunset.
That’s what made the initial announcement of “The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth” so bewildering: not only is Tarantino circumventing his 10th-and-final-film rule, but he wrote a continuation that would be handed off to David Fincher of all people to direct. It was a combination that felt like the most implausible April Fool’s joke of all time, but it also brought Brad Pitt back together with two filmmakers who’ve done nothing but bring the best out of him. It’s a partnership that, while sounding antithetical to their styles of filmmaking, actually fares far better than most skeptics would’ve anticipated. Fincher’s acidity spills instantly within the film’s opening moments.
It’s 1977, and Cliff is long past the days of doubling as Rick’s stunt double and putting down hippie home invaders. He’s a bit older, limping around his part-time gig at the New Beverly Cinema (of course) or bartending his nights away crafting fruity cocktails. The film follows Cliff through the motions, watching him work the projector, relieve adolescent employees of their shifts, pound a few beers, and mouth every word to blaxploitation flicks starring Yahya Abdul-Mateen II’s Roderick “Hot Rod” Harrison. The hair is shaggier, the mustache is flowing, but Cliff’s disarmingly charming personality remains intact. It makes his propensity for violence permeate all the more alarmingly, especially with the manner Fincher captures brutality compared to the stylization of Tarantino.
With “The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth,” Tarantino’s screenplay undoubtedly still rings true to his style even with another filmmaker at the helm. It’s the closest he’s been to “Jackie Brown” territory, playing more in a literary paperback-noir manner akin to Elmore Leonard. The days-of-the-week structure the film follows, while humorous, occasionally meanders, which clashes with Fincher’s tight-knit editing style. Yet Fincher reins it in, especially with his ability to let loose. Viewers watch Cliff’s vagabond energy lead him to various locales across California, where he finds himself at the request of Hollywood big shots desperate for a man with his reputation.
For most of the film, one wonders where Tarantino is taking the story, and some will be frustrated trying to map every corner of Cliff’s journey. While this certainly isn’t as laissez-faire as its predecessor, “The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth” doesn’t mind taking a few pit stops, whether it’s in race car derbies or pompous country clubs. Tarantino’s world-building is as absorbing as ever, and Fincher adds plenty, not only putting his own spin on it but making it feel like a worthy companion piece. The film truly thrives on the relationships Cliff cultivates throughout his busy week. Whether it’s his gruff, pawn-shop-owning father Gus, played by Peter Weller, or the sultry Hollywood agent Karen Crosby, played by Elizabeth Debicki, who feeds into a dommy-mommy fixation in the former stuntman’s heart, it’s endearing to see characters, no matter their mal intentions, be won over by Cliff.
In large part, it’s because this is one of, if not the defining, characters of Pitt’s career. Fincher is the first filmmaker in a few years to awaken something inside of the Academy Award-winning actor. Pitt, a performer comfortable coasting on his movie-star persona, hasn’t been this alive on screen since “Babylon,” taking his real-life magnetism and baking it into that mysterious energy that makes Cliff so alluring. Fincher, of course, doesn’t leave it at that, parsing a sense of acceptance buried deep within a man who rolls with the punches life throws at him. Pitt isn’t typically an actor vying for these transformational heavy performances, but it’s easy to see him disappear into the role until only Cliff Booth remains.
The ensemble that populates the personalities Cliff encounters is, to no one’s surprise, fantastic, especially Scott Caan as Charlie Peters, a smashing television star of his day desperate for Cliff’s advice, roping him into more than he can handle. Caan delivers his best performance, playing a short-fused Hollywood blowhard who is equally as egotistical as he is smarmy. Caan makes for a worthy on-screen nuisance, especially with his testy on-screen rapport with Pitt. It’s Debicki, though, who rises to the top with such an electric presence. Karen’s dynamic with Cliff may be the most romantic pairing of Tarantino characters since Jackie and Max. It’s the heartbeat of the film and one of the firmer aspects of the narrative. Karen’s character might also be the only living remnant of Tarantino’s famously scrapped feature, “The Movie Critic,” with Tarantino certainly getting some things off his chest, including a sly dig at “Star Wars.”
Apprehensions towards Fincher’s direction, mainly his digital-first filmmaking and how that contrasts with “Once Upon a Time in…Hollywood,” are warranted at times with this follow-up. If anyone had to shoot this feature, it makes sense Fincher would enlist his frequent collaborator Erik Messerschmidt to capture this sullied late-70s California. His work is, in fact, so perfect at establishing the visual language for Fincher’s deviation that whenever Jeff Cronenweth steps in as cinematographer (due to reshoots when Messerschmidt was unavailable), it’s all the more noticeable. What is noticeably distracting is Fincher’s use of generative AI in key moments of the film, which is nothing but an eyesore. Sure, he’s a filmmaker always at the forefront of technological advancements in his craft, yet like many others, he’s been duped into thinking it’s not only something people want to see, but something that even looks good.
Even with these slight hiccups, the world Tarantino, Pitt, and now Fincher have brought to life remains irresistible for devoted fans of “Once Upon a Time in…Hollywood.” There’s ample appeal in the ever-evolving shit Cliff finds himself stepping into, especially with the adrenaline-spiking, pulp-heavy conclusion Fincher delivers. If “Once Upon a Time in…Hollywood” was a tribute to the Hollywood that once was, “The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth” probes whether what Cliff and Rick did on that fateful August night in 1969 would’ve even made a difference. Luckily for audiences, it’s not for Tarantino or even Fincher to tell. At the end of the day, both of them have been in business long enough to know not to get in the way of a good story.

