Having been in theaters for nearly a month, it’s undeniable that “You Can See Everything” is one of the most talked about and celebrated films of the year. Despite being a documentary made by filmmakers who are far from industry regulars, it has established itself as enough of a sensation to be a sure bet to get recognized at the forthcoming Academy Awards. While the Oscars are more flexible with their rules, allowing a documentary to get recognized in other categories, not every awards body is as liberal with their eligibility, making the road to the Oscars a unique one for this movie. Oscar predictors have been programmed to rely on precursors like the BAFTAs, Golden Globes, and guild awards, but with Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s opus automatically shut out in categories at several of these, how will that affect its perception throughout the season and the race for a potential Best Picture?
To start, it’s perhaps best to list off the places where it won’t be in play. Perhaps the biggest and most recently announced exclusion is that the film will not be contending in the main feature category at the Directors Guild Awards. Considering there is a separate Documentary Feature category, it’s not too surprising, but given the unique nature of the film there was some thought it would maybe play in both fields. While they aren’t eligible to get recognized in the feature race, a nearly guaranteed win in the Documentary Feature category will still be a good moment of guild support for the directing pair. The film is, however, eligible at the Producers Guild Awards for their top prize, and it’d be curious to see how close to a win it could potentially get. Given the breakout nature of the film commercially and how it has captured the zeitgeist in such an unexpected way, especially for a three hour documentary, the angle is there for it to be rewarded by producers. Going against the much more successful and traditionally commercial “The Odyssey” would certainly be a hurdle to getting such a win, but it’s exciting that it’s even a possibility for such an upset to occur. Does it need to win PGA if it wants to win Best Picture at the Oscars? It certainly would be helpful, but this film is going to be such a wild card at every turn that it could still surprise at the final stage after losing something like this.
When it comes to more international bodies, the film will be ineligible across the board at the Golden Globes, apart from maybe the Cinematic and Box Office Achievement award if it’s submitted there. While there’s obviously no voter overlap between Globes and Oscars, one of the big contenders being absent from one of the major award shows certainly does sting and is a hit to its momentum, when every other film it’s competing against can be celebrated. However, BAFTA – although it’s much later in the season – will have the film contending everywhere except for one category (we’ll get to that later), but it’ll be interesting if the film is as big a juggernaut with overseas audiences as it has been in the states. The film is just now rolling out internationally, so we will start to see the early signs of that soon, but it’s very likely that BAFTA will be where the film’s awards potential becomes fully clear. With nominations for BAFTA only two days before the Oscars, it’ll likely be a last minute insight into how excited the international voters are about the film, which will be crucial in seeing how high it can go at the Academy Awards.
The Critics Choice Awards is the only precursor whose eligibility rules line up entirely with the Academy Awards, which, despite the lack of voter overlap, will be a good reflection of its strength early in the season. With the body and voting history of CCA, they’ll likely be very generous in awarding the film and are almost certainly the ones who would be most excited to give the film their top prize. They can even give the film Best Picture and Best Director if the Oscars don’t, but their rewarding of the film will likely align with how critics groups have already treated it at the start of the season. These organizations will be the most important stepping stone for the film, especially in its contention for wins; given the critical support for the film and its unconventional standing as a contender, it needs critics groups to be go bananas for it if it wants to be in the conversation as a contender for wins. In most recent years, contenders exist in one category or another that weren’t expected to show up because of past precedent, but critic prizes are always the first to dispel these narratives and establish a contender as the real deal.
What’s funny about the documentary’s spotty qualifications throughout the year is how it allows the film to remain a wild card throughout the whole season. If critics really go to bat for it, including the Critics Choice, all of the wins other films receive at the major bodies will have an asterisk next to them for not having to compete with “You Can See Everything.” Even if it loses at places where it’s eligible like BAFTA or PGA, being the first documentary nominated at all these precursors gives it leeway to be considered for a surprise upset at the very end. If “The Odyssey” wins at all these bodies it’ll be hard for most to bet against it, but there will always be something compelling about “You Can See Everything,” kind of in a similar way that “Parasite” had clear support all year that materialized at the last moment. Perhaps this is setting ourselves up for disappointment, but the level of buzz this has and how unique of a contender it is certainly allows for such excitement.
Then comes the big mystery of this film’s awards prospects, and that’s the notion of Amanda Seyfried as a Best Supporting Actress contender. She’d be the first and likely only time we will ever have to contend with a performance like this in awards contention, and that makes considering her all the more confusing ahead of critics groups. Considering most of her screen time in the film is her as herself, the excitement around her work is largely for the filmmaker’s choice to include her. This isn’t to undermine the work she does in Fielder’s classic recreations, where she brilliantly reprises her role as Elizabeth Holmes, but it can certainly result in her getting gatekept by the acting branch of the Academy. On that note, the only place she is eligible to be nominated is Critics Choice, so she would likely have to be mentioned and maybe even win there if she wants to be secure for the Oscar nomination. With how beloved she is and how excited people are about her being in the film, it’s more than possible for critics groups and the CCA to give her wins, and that would be all she would need to stay in the conversation for the Oscars. It certainly will be interesting to see what happens given her being kept out from BAFTA, the Globes, and the Actor Awards, but an eventual Oscar nomination would only prove the strength of the film.
It will be a fun season to see how far a contender of this nature can climb, given all the spots we know it will miss. The unprecedented nature of it as an awards contender is exciting enough, but the uncertainty that it’s guaranteed to have all year will hopefully lead to some extra exciting results.
Do you think “You Can See Everything” has a chance to win Best Picture? What other awards do you think it could win? Please let us know in the comments section below and on Next Best Picture’s X account, and check out Next Best Picture’s latest Oscar predictions here.

